Follow us on Google News
Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed
Beef between celebrities is certainly not uncommon in the entertainment industry. While some may openly talk about their distaste for each other, others leave room for speculation. Now, netizens are noticing a possible underlying beef betweenI Know What You Did Last Summer(1997) actresses, Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt.

The slasher film follows the story of a group of young adults who accidentally commit a murder and decide to form a pact to bury the news. However, their past catches up to them rather quickly. Considered to be a timeless addition to the genre,I Know What You Did Last Summeris currently working on a reboot. Although, it looks like the two stars might not be too stoked to possibly be working with each other. Or at least that’s what the Internet believes.
Sarah Michelle Gellar’s red carpet moment has fans talking
Sarah Michelle Gellarrecently bumped into Extra TV at the NYC premiere ofDexter: Original Sin.There, she was asked about theI Know What You Did Last Summerreboot.
Another OG Star From ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ Could Be Returning in Sony’s New Sequel, Latest Update Reveals
Praising what’s to come, Gellar stated that the“script is so much fun.”However, her demeanor changed rather quickly when the reporter brought upJennifer Love Hewitt’s possible return to the franchise with the reboot.
Plastering a smile and shrugging, Gellar simply replied,“I have nothing to do with that”before trying to exit the interview. After watching this short clip, the Internet was convinced that there is an underlying tension between the two actresses and that they might even have a possible beef with each other.

Take a look at some of the things people have said:
Sarah Michelle Gellar was asked if Jennifer Love Hewitt is returning to the I Know What You Did Last Summer reboot:Look at her face!! 😭😂She hates her so bad!sksksksk💀💀💀#IKWYDLS#iknowwhatyoudidlastsummerpic.twitter.com/FOiCzNs7KH

She really saidpic.twitter.com/MBYkErmDqd
Oh wow! I felt that coldness!
She tried to runaway quick 😭
Damn, that energy shift

Now, it is completely possible that Gellar was simply trying to keep herself from giving out spoilers or that she actually had no idea about Hewitt’s involvement in the reboot. But hey, sometimes the Internet sees what it wants to see!
Is Jennifer Love Hewitt coming to theI Know What You Did Last Summerreboot?
Hewitt played the role of Julie James in the franchise and now, with the untitled reboot being a direct sequel toI Still Know What You Did Last Summer(1998), we are wondering if the fan favorite Julie will be returning for the reboot or not.
She recently paid a visit to theI’ve Never Said This Before With Tommy DiDariopodcast where she was asked about the possibility. Hewitt ignited the flame of hope in the hearts of her fans when she stated,“I am possibly preparing for that. I am so close to being able to say something that’s exciting.”

“There was no way for her to do both”: Even Hardcore Criminal Minds Fans Will Forgive Jennifer Love Hewitt after Knowing the Real Reason Kate Callahan Left the Show
Sounds like a yes to us! Of course, nothing is official until it is official.
Hewitt added that if she does return to the franchise, she wants to do something that is meaningful and not simply dwell on the past.
It has only been scheduling and me trying to make sure that if I go back to the franchise, I just don’t want to be the ghost of ’90s past. I really want to do something, and I want to be there for Julie James fans… I just want it to feel like, you know, if she comes back then it means something.
Directed byJennifer Kaytin Robinson, the untitled reboot is scheduled for a release on August 12, 2025, and the cast includesMadelyn Cline, Sarah Pidgeon,Jonah Hauer-King, and more.
Mishkaat Khan
Senior Writer
Articles Published :2256
A connoisseur of all things horror, fantasy, and the occasional chick flick, Mishkaat has been penning pieces for FandomWire since 2022. She started off as an intern and has worked her way up to a Senior Writer with over 2000 articles to her name.Outside of entertainment, she has also written well-researched medical content as a freelance writer and has experience in social media management.When not writing, you can find her relaxing with a romance novel and a tall glass of iced coffee in her hand or watching re-runs of ‘Supernatural’ and ‘The Office.’