Follow us on Google News

Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed

Eiichiro Oda’sOne Piecehas been serialized in the Weekly Shonen Jump since 1997. Over the years, the Shonen series has featured several characters that have redefined the meaning of strength. However, one name stayed on top, it was none other than Edward Newgate, the Captain of the Whitebeard Pirates.

A still from One Piece

The pirate was the longest-serving Emperor of the Sea of the Previous Generation and claimed the title of ‘Strongest Man in the World.’ His raw physical strength and the unmatched power of the Gura Gura no Mi reinforced the title given to him. However, some fans claim that one other name is way stronger than the notorious pirate.

Monkey D. Garp showcased his strength at Hachinosu, the base of the Blackbeard Pirates, where he disobeyed the orders from his superiors to save Koby. As a result, some fans claim that the Vice Admiral is way above the deceased pirate. However, they are wrong because of one important aspect.

Monkey D Garp defeated Blackbeard Pirates

Whitebeard Proves Why Garp Doesn’t Fall in His League

The debate and anticipation following the strongest character inEiichiro Oda’sOne Piecehave often been a matter of question. A lot of names are worthy contenders, but recently one name has been believed to stand above the rest. Recently, when the Blackbeard Pirates made Koby their prisoner,Monkey D. Garpdid everything in his power to ensure that his subordinate was freed from the malicious clutches of Marshall D. Teach.

During the fight, the Vice Admiral destroyed the antagonist group, making the fandom believe that he might be the new ‘Strongest Man in the World.’ Although he was beaten up quite badly, it is nothing compared to the stern punishment inflicted on the Emperor of the Sea.

“At least everyone else gets to keep their bodily autonomy…”: Anime Fans Aren’t Ready for the Saddest One Piece Storyline That Makes Robin and Sanji’s Backstory Seem Forgivable

“At least everyone else gets to keep their bodily autonomy…”: Anime Fans Aren’t Ready for the Saddest One Piece Storyline That Makes Robin and Sanji’s Backstory Seem Forgivable

During the whole Marineford War, he had Stage 4 cancer, was stabbed 267 times, had 152 bullet wounds, 46 cannonball wounds, and three powerful magma punches; amidst all this, he died standing with his back never touching the ground. On the other hand, The Hero of the Marines was stabbed twice, received one Ice Glove in the face, and fell down two times.

While it can be judged that the two are on a similar level, this is where Garp fans are wrong. According toCuriouslyEnough, a creator on YouTube, old Whitebeard is stronger than old Garp because of one aspect.

A still from One Piece

One Piece: Forget Gear 5 Luffy, Usopp Can Get the Most Terrifying Power Update That Will Make Shanks’ Future Sight Almost Useless That Oda Has Been Foreshadowing for Years

They stated that the age gap between them created all the difference in the world. The creator said,

But Whitebeard far surpassed Garp in endurance. Additionally, Garp is 78 years old, six years older than Whitebeard. This age gap is not like going from 20 to 26, as aging in your 70s typically leads to decreased strength, not increased.

One Piece: Forget Gear 5 Luffy, Usopp Can Get the Most Terrifying Power Update That Will Make Shanks’ Future Sight Almost Useless That Oda Has Been Foreshadowing for Years

This news summoned the entireOne Piececommunity to the YouTube post, where they did not shy away from supporting their views.

One PieceFans React To How Garp is Weaker than Whitebeard

The fans of the Hero of the Marine were heartbroken but did not feel disappointed because he did not possess a Devil Fruit to have additional power; he solely relied on his raw physical strength and Haki to take down his foes.

He fought alongside Gol D. Roger to take down Rocks D. Xebec, which gave him the nickname he is known for, solely because it was immensely difficult. Hence, the fandom shared their thoughts on the post, choosing their side between the two characters.

@Theblackhaireddude commented,“Don’t forget, garp all fists. No weapon or world-bending DF. Also Garp was fighting someone he’d never kill.”

@GryphonEdit commented,“Whitebeard “Even the death couldn’t bring this man down to his knees” Surely lived up to his name”

@gunlevis403 commented,“remember that WB came to Marineford with a whole fleet and strong enough captains ready to support him, while Garp only had a small fleet and he was the one doing it all”

@Retro4Bit commented,“Garp actually accomplished his mission tho…. Just saying”

@strawkidful commented,“One using a fruit to destroy the world, and the other only need love fist”

@senpaichazak commented,“Garp just got defeated. He even just stopped fighting when Garp knows Coby and the Slaves are escaping. He can just do a suicide bomb by releasing another galaxy impact but he just stopped and laugh”

“He is 3X the size of the Colossal Titan”: The One Piece Character from Eiichiro Oda’s World That Absolutely Dwarfs Hajime Isayama’s Most Invincible Creation

Nevertheless, there’s no denying that these two characters have the strongest names and have been immensely loved by theOPcommunity. As a result, their presence has taken Oda-Sensei’s magnum opus to a whole new level, which has established it as the best Shonen series to ever exist.

One Piececan be streamed on Crunchyroll as of August 17th, 2024.

Tushar Auddy

Senior Writer

Articles Published :1784

Tushar Auddy is a Senior Writer at FandomWire, primarily covering WWE. He has contributed to anime, MCU, DCU, animation, and TV Series, giving sharp insights and coming up with his own unique theories, which take the fandom by storm.

More from Tushar Auddy

WWE RAW Tonight (August 18): Roman Reigns’ Match at Clash in Paris Receives Bizarre Update After Show Goes Off Air

Why Karrion Kross Should Sign With TNA Instead of AEW After WWE Exit

WWE: After 11 Years of Marriage, Naomi and Jimmy Uso Announce First Pregnancy

NYT Pips Solution for June 21, 2025

‘Game of Thrones’ Cast Ranked by Net Worth: Who’s the Richest GOT Actor?

Every Makoto Shinkai Main Character Ranked From Worst to Best

‘Lord of Mysteries’ and ‘To Be Hero X’ Are Giving ‘One Piece’ a Massive Reality Check

10 Actors You Didn’t Know Were in Smallville: From Dave Bautista to Cobie Smulders

NYT Connections Hints and Solution for August 22, 2025

Eiichiro OdaMonkey D. GarpOne PieceWhitebeard